| Monsignor Leo B. Donovan
1957 - 1967 |
| Reverend Robert F. Hart
1967 - 1987 |
| Reverend David V. Berberian
1987 - 1992 |
| Reverend Patrick J. Butler
1992 - 2006 |
| Reverend James T. Fitzmaurice
2007 - Present |